| Seed | Wrestler | Team | Choice | Choice no team |
| #1 | Spencer Lee | IOWA | #1 Spencer Lee (IOWA) | #1 Spencer Lee |
| #2 | Sam Latona | VT | #2 Sam Latona (VT) | #2 Sam Latona |
| #3 | Brandon Courtney | ASU | #3 Brandon Courtney (ASU) | #3 Brandon Courtney |
| #4 | Drew Hildebrandt | CMU | #4 Drew Hildebrandt (CMU) | #4 Drew Hildebrandt |
| #5 | Brody Teske | UNI | #5 Brody Teske (UNI) | #5 Brody Teske |
| #6 | Jakob Camacho | NCST | #6 Jakob Camacho (NCST) | #6 Jakob Camacho |
| #7 | Taylor LaMont | UVU | #7 Taylor LaMont (UVU) | #7 Taylor LaMont |
| #8 | RayVon Foley | MSU | #8 RayVon Foley (MSU) | #8 RayVon Foley |
| #9 | Devin Schroder | PUR | #9 Devin Schroder (PUR) | #9 Devin Schroder |
| #10 | Malik Heinselman | OHST | #10 Malik Heinselman (OHST) | #10 Malik Heinselman |
| #11 | Dylan Ragusin | MICH | #11 Dylan Ragusin (MICH) | #11 Dylan Ragusin |
| #12 | Michael DeAugustino | NW | #12 Michael DeAugustino (NW) | #12 Michael DeAugustino |
| #13 | Liam Cronin | NEB | #13 Liam Cronin (NEB) | #13 Liam Cronin |
| #14 | Jaret Lane | LEH | #14 Jaret Lane (LEH) | #14 Jaret Lane |
| #15 | Patrick McKee | MINN | #15 Patrick McKee (MINN) | #15 Patrick McKee |
| #16 | Codi Russell | APP | #16 Codi Russell (APP) | #16 Codi Russell |
| #17 | Killian Cardinale | WVU | #17 Killian Cardinale (WVU) | #17 Killian Cardinale |
| #18 | Noah Surtin | MIZZ | #18 Noah Surtin (MIZZ) | #18 Noah Surtin |
| #19 | Eric Barnett | WIS | #19 Eric Barnett (WIS) | #19 Eric Barnett |
| #20 | Jake Ferri | KENT | #20 Jake Ferri (KENT) | #20 Jake Ferri |
| #21 | Trevor Mastrogiovanni | OKST | #21 Trevor Mastrogiovanni (OKST) | #21 Trevor Mastrogiovanni |
| #22 | Daniel Vega | SDSU | #22 Daniel Vega (SDSU) | #22 Daniel Vega |
| #23 | Robert Howard | PSU | #23 Robert Howard (PSU) | #23 Robert Howard |
| #24 | Fabian Gutierrez | CHAT | #24 Fabian Gutierrez (CHAT) | #24 Fabian Gutierrez |
| #25 | Logan Treaster | NAVY | #25 Logan Treaster (NAVY) | #25 Logan Treaster |
| #26 | Jackson DiSario | STAN | #26 Jackson DiSario (STAN) | #26 Jackson DiSario |
| #27 | Gage Curry | AMER | #27 Gage Curry (AMER) | #27 Gage Curry |
| #28 | Brandon Kaylor | ORST | #28 Brandon Kaylor (ORST) | #28 Brandon Kaylor |
| #29 | Zurich Storm | CAMP | #29 Zurich Storm (CAMP) | #29 Zurich Storm |
| #30 | Micah Roes | BING | #30 Micah Roes (BING) | #30 Micah Roes |
| #31 | Jonathan Tropea | RID | #31 Jonathan Tropea (RID) | #31 Jonathan Tropea |
| #32 | Patrick McCormick | UVA | #32 Patrick McCormick (UVA) | #32 Patrick McCormick |
| #33 | Kysen Terukina | ISU | #33 Kysen Terukina (ISU) | #33 Kysen Terukina |