| Seed | Wrestler | Team | Choice | Choice no team |
| #1 | Daton Fix | OKST | #1 Daton Fix (OKST) | #1 Daton Fix |
| #2 | Roman Bravo-Young | PSU | #2 Roman Bravo-Young (PSU) | #2 Roman Bravo-Young |
| #3 | Korbin Myers | VT | #3 Korbin Myers (VT) | #3 Korbin Myers |
| #4 | Austin DeSanto | IOWA | #4 Austin DeSanto (IOWA) | #4 Austin DeSanto |
| #5 | Micky Phillippi | PITT | #5 Micky Phillippi (PITT) | #5 Micky Phillippi |
| #6 | Matt Schmitt | MIZZ | #6 Matt Schmitt (MIZZ) | #6 Matt Schmitt |
| #7 | Lucas Byrd | ILL | #7 Lucas Byrd (ILL) | #7 Lucas Byrd |
| #8 | Chris Cannon | NW | #8 Chris Cannon (NW) | #8 Chris Cannon |
| #9 | Michael McGee | ASU | #9 Michael McGee (ASU) | #9 Michael McGee |
| #10 | Louie Hayes | UVA | #10 Louie Hayes (UVA) | #10 Louie Hayes |
| #11 | Anthony Madrigal | OU | #11 Anthony Madrigal (OU) | #11 Anthony Madrigal |
| #12 | Jarrett Trombley | NCST | #12 Jarrett Trombley (NCST) | #12 Jarrett Trombley |
| #13 | Zach Redding | ISU | #13 Zach Redding (ISU) | #13 Zach Redding |
| #14 | Zach Price | SDSU | #14 Zach Price (SDSU) | #14 Zach Price |
| #15 | Mosha Schwartz | UNCO | #15 Mosha Schwartz (UNCO) | #15 Mosha Schwartz |
| #16 | Devan Turner | ORST | #16 Devan Turner (ORST) | #16 Devan Turner |
| #17 | Malyke Hines | LEH | #17 Malyke Hines (LEH) | #17 Malyke Hines |
| #18 | Kyle Burwick | WIS | #18 Kyle Burwick (WIS) | #18 Kyle Burwick |
| #19 | Chance Rich | CSUB | #19 Chance Rich (CSUB) | #19 Chance Rich |
| #20 | Ryan Sullivan | WVU | #20 Ryan Sullivan (WVU) | #20 Ryan Sullivan |
| #21 | Jared Van Vleet | AF | #21 Jared Van Vleet (AF) | #21 Jared Van Vleet |
| #22 | Mario Guillen | OHIO | #22 Mario Guillen (OHIO) | #22 Mario Guillen |
| #23 | Boo Dryden | MINN | #23 Boo Dryden (MINN) | #23 Boo Dryden |
| #24 | Richie Koehler | RID | #24 Richie Koehler (RID) | #24 Richie Koehler |
| #25 | Jacob Rundell | PUR | #25 Jacob Rundell (PUR) | #25 Jacob Rundell |
| #26 | Darren Miller | BUCK | #26 Darren Miller (BUCK) | #26 Darren Miller |
| #27 | Jacob Allen | NAVY | #27 Jacob Allen (NAVY) | #27 Jacob Allen |
| #28 | Ty Smith | UVU | #28 Ty Smith (UVU) | #28 Ty Smith |
| #29 | Paul Bianchi | LR | #29 Paul Bianchi (LR) | #29 Paul Bianchi |
| #30 | Jordan Hamdan | MSU | #30 Jordan Hamdan (MSU) | #30 Jordan Hamdan |
| #31 | Sean Carter | APP | #31 Sean Carter (APP) | #31 Sean Carter |
| #32 | Cole Rhone | BLOO | #32 Cole Rhone (BLOO) | #32 Cole Rhone |
| #33 | Bryce West | NIU | #33 Bryce West (NIU) | #33 Bryce West |