| Seed | Wrestler | Team | Choice | Choice no team |
| #1 | Ryan Deakin | NW | #1 Ryan Deakin (NW) | #1 Ryan Deakin |
| #2 | Hayden Hidlay | NCST | #2 Hayden Hidlay (NCST) | #2 Hayden Hidlay |
| #3 | David Carr | ISU | #3 David Carr (ISU) | #3 David Carr |
| #4 | Jesse Dellavecchia | RID | #4 Jesse Dellavecchia (RID) | #4 Jesse Dellavecchia |
| #5 | Kaleb Young | IOWA | #5 Kaleb Young (IOWA) | #5 Kaleb Young |
| #6 | Brayton Lee | MINN | #6 Brayton Lee (MINN) | #6 Brayton Lee |
| #7 | Jarrett Jacques | MIZZ | #7 Jarrett Jacques (MIZZ) | #7 Jarrett Jacques |
| #8 | Jared Franek | NDSU | #8 Jared Franek (NDSU) | #8 Jared Franek |
| #9 | Kendall Coleman | PUR | #9 Kendall Coleman (PUR) | #9 Kendall Coleman |
| #10 | Justin Thomas | OU | #10 Justin Thomas (OU) | #10 Justin Thomas |
| #11 | Jacori Teemer | ASU | #11 Jacori Teemer (ASU) | #11 Jacori Teemer |
| #12 | Brady Berge | PSU | #12 Brady Berge (PSU) | #12 Brady Berge |
| #13 | Hunter Willits | ORST | #13 Hunter Willits (ORST) | #13 Hunter Willits |
| #14 | Will Lewan | MICH | #14 Will Lewan (MICH) | #14 Will Lewan |
| #15 | Chase Saldate | MSU | #15 Chase Saldate (MSU) | #15 Chase Saldate |
| #16 | Justin McCoy | UVA | #16 Justin McCoy (UVA) | #16 Justin McCoy |
| #17 | Requir van der Merwe | STAN | #17 Requir van der Merwe (STAN) | #17 Requir van der Merwe |
| #18 | Cade DeVos | SDSU | #18 Cade DeVos (SDSU) | #18 Cade DeVos |
| #19 | Holden Heller | HOF | #19 Holden Heller (HOF) | #19 Holden Heller |
| #20 | Cody Bond | APP | #20 Cody Bond (APP) | #20 Cody Bond |
| #21 | Andrew Cerniglia | NAVY | #21 Andrew Cerniglia (NAVY) | #21 Andrew Cerniglia |
| #22 | Benjamin Barton | CAMP | #22 Benjamin Barton (CAMP) | #22 Benjamin Barton |
| #23 | Jacob Wright | WYO | #23 Jacob Wright (WYO) | #23 Jacob Wright |
| #24 | Nicholas Palumbo | SH | #24 Nicholas Palumbo (SH) | #24 Nicholas Palumbo |
| #25 | Parker Kropman | DREX | #25 Parker Kropman (DREX) | #25 Parker Kropman |
| #26 | Johnny Lovett | CMU | #26 Johnny Lovett (CMU) | #26 Johnny Lovett |
| #27 | Connor Brady | VT | #27 Connor Brady (VT) | #27 Connor Brady |
| #28 | Caleb Licking | NEB | #28 Caleb Licking (NEB) | #28 Caleb Licking |
| #29 | Joshua McClure | UNC | #29 Joshua McClure (UNC) | #29 Joshua McClure |
| #30 | Markus Hartman | ARMY | #30 Markus Hartman (ARMY) | #30 Markus Hartman |
| #31 | Michael Petite | BUFF | #31 Michael Petite (BUFF) | #31 Michael Petite |
| #32 | Luca Frinzi | LEH | #32 Luca Frinzi (LEH) | #32 Luca Frinzi |
| #33 | Wyatt Sheets | OKST | #33 Wyatt Sheets (OKST) | #33 Wyatt Sheets |