| Seed | Wrestler | Team | Choice | Choice no team |
| #1 | Michael Kemerer | IOWA | #1 Michael Kemerer (IOWA) | #1 Michael Kemerer |
| #2 | Demetrius Romero | UVU | #2 Demetrius Romero (UVU) | #2 Demetrius Romero |
| #3 | Carter Starocci | PSU | #3 Carter Starocci (PSU) | #3 Carter Starocci |
| #4 | Mikey Labriola | NEB | #4 Mikey Labriola (NEB) | #4 Mikey Labriola |
| #5 | Logan Massa | MICH | #5 Logan Massa (MICH) | #5 Logan Massa |
| #6 | Andrew McNally | KENT | #6 Andrew McNally (KENT) | #6 Andrew McNally |
| #7 | Kaleb Romero | OHST | #7 Kaleb Romero (OHST) | #7 Kaleb Romero |
| #8 | Daniel Bullard | NCST | #8 Daniel Bullard (NCST) | #8 Daniel Bullard |
| #9 | Donnell Washington | IND | #9 Donnell Washington (IND) | #9 Donnell Washington |
| #10 | Peyton Mocco | MIZZ | #10 Peyton Mocco (MIZZ) | #10 Peyton Mocco |
| #11 | Austin Murphy | CAMP | #11 Austin Murphy (CAMP) | #11 Austin Murphy |
| #12 | Bernie Truax | POLY | #12 Bernie Truax (POLY) | #12 Bernie Truax |
| #13 | Jackson Hemauer | UNCO | #13 Jackson Hemauer (UNCO) | #13 Jackson Hemauer |
| #14 | Hayden Hastings | WYO | #14 Hayden Hastings (WYO) | #14 Hayden Hastings |
| #15 | Thomas Flitz | APP | #15 Thomas Flitz (APP) | #15 Thomas Flitz |
| #16 | Clay Lautt | UNC | #16 Clay Lautt (UNC) | #16 Clay Lautt |
| #17 | Benjamin Pasiuk | ARMY | #17 Benjamin Pasiuk (ARMY) | #17 Benjamin Pasiuk |
| #18 | Dustin Plott | OKST | #18 Dustin Plott (OKST) | #18 Dustin Plott |
| #19 | Michael O`Malley | DREX | #19 Michael O`Malley (DREX) | #19 Michael O`Malley |
| #20 | Trenton Munoz | ASU | #20 Trenton Munoz (ASU) | #20 Trenton Munoz |
| #21 | Jacob Oliver | EDIN | #21 Jacob Oliver (EDIN) | #21 Jacob Oliver |
| #22 | Mason Kauffman | NIU | #22 Mason Kauffman (NIU) | #22 Mason Kauffman |
| #23 | Anthony Mantanona | OU | #23 Anthony Mantanona (OU) | #23 Anthony Mantanona |
| #24 | Jake Allar | MINN | #24 Jake Allar (MINN) | #24 Jake Allar |
| #25 | Cody Surratt | AF | #25 Cody Surratt (AF) | #25 Cody Surratt |
| #26 | Jackson Turley | RUT | #26 Jackson Turley (RUT) | #26 Jackson Turley |
| #27 | Cody Howard | VT | #27 Cody Howard (VT) | #27 Cody Howard |
| #28 | Timothy Fitzpatrick | AMER | #28 Timothy Fitzpatrick (AMER) | #28 Timothy Fitzpatrick |
| #29 | Lance Runyon | UNI | #29 Lance Runyon (UNI) | #29 Lance Runyon |
| #30 | Victor Marcelli | UVA | #30 Victor Marcelli (UVA) | #30 Victor Marcelli |
| #31 | Jake Logan | LEH | #31 Jake Logan (LEH) | #31 Jake Logan |
| #32 | Drew Hughes | MSU | #32 Drew Hughes (MSU) | #32 Drew Hughes |
| #33 | Jacob Nolan | BING | #33 Jacob Nolan (BING) | #33 Jacob Nolan |